Since it was my first time here, I…" Enjoy entrees like Mim's meat loaf, pecan-crusted sole, or filet mignon. I love the buffalo spring rolls and the filet mignon steak sandwich is outrageous ! RichI've been coming to the Mill Creek Tavern for a few years now and the food is always fantastic. We had drinks, fish tacos, sole franchese and eggplant parm. The four of us were attracted to their three-course early-bird special at $28.95 plus a first-timers $10 coupon. -RichBeyond great-awesome food-welcoming & efficient staff.Wow!! We let the waitress know, and left for a restaurant that would be more attentive something like this. "I've been waiting for quite some time to try this place. The owner and staff, especially Vanessa, always cater to our every need or want.Thanks for the awesome 5 star review!! My wife ordered the…"Long Island's most popular neighborhood restaurants, Mill Creek Tavern serves seasonal robustly flavored, American cuisine in a relaxed setting of casual elegance. Have a great day - RichPicked up our food while waiting in the car. We look forward to seeing you soon. Eggplant parm was a bit to greasy for my taste. Nice salads too. Please order from here if you can. Thank you so much God Bless -RIchAlways great food and service. Right now we are offering our family meals deals for non-contact curbside…"Find more American (Traditional) Restaurants near Mill Creek Tavern Was there twice the past month! I thought the offer,…""My wife and I almost didn't eat lunch here based upon a 1-star review by Brad R.. We look forward to seeing you again soon. I can't wait to go to happy hour post pandemic!Hi Jennifer, thank you so much for this amazing five star review, and for support us in this difficult time. God bless you and your family, stay safe and be strong.. We are forever grateful. Bayville, NY Mill Creek Catering & Events We Specialize in Elegant Weddings, Cocktail Parties, New England Lobster Bakes, Southern Pig Roasts, Casual B.B.Q's or Drop -Off Trays. I am so thrilled your birthday was not ruined and you got to spend it with the crew at Mill Creek, and most of all Vanessa. We look forward to serving you again soon - RichMet a friend for dinner after the Christmas holiday and decided to go to the Mill Creek Tavern

Thank you for supporting us, HAPPY BIRTHDAY and God Bless you and your family -Rich"Here's the Scoop: This place use to be the home of the Country Buffet. I would also like to thank you for your loyalty for the past two years. Win-win for all!Thank you Pierre for the wonderful four star review. For my entree my mom and I shared the tuna and the sauerbraten short rib. The drinks are great too! Bayville strong! So when we arrived we had no clue that it was a Chinese Buffet. After the owner personally reached out to me I decided to re-visit the restaurant last night for dinner.

Some friends told my husband and I that it was now a different buffet. In a time when anxiety is overwhelming, It is such a relief and break from reality to have fresh, hot and delicious meals from my hometown eatery. God bless you and your family. I can't thank you all enough for salvaging my birthday!! The lady that seated us was so informative about their procedures and then handed us over to Sue our server who was so great. God Bless you and your family. They have a special every weekday half price appetizers at the bar and the bartenders Kathy & Mike really make you feel at home. The buffalo chicken rolls were awesome  and the chicken francese was tender and delicious. We are grateful for guests like yourself. There was a young man who was cleaning up tables around and he made sure our cups were full of water the whole time.

The Food is consistently good to excellent.It's just a few blocks over the bridge into Bayville, has a long bar area and much more dining space. - RichGreat dinner at Mill Creek Tavern again...My friends and I came back for dinner to try the early bird special that runs from 4:30pm - 6:30pm daily. Behind the bar, an outstanding wine list, local micro-brews and a large selection of hand-crafted specialty cocktails are offered. Certainly not worth the high price. Have a great day. Substitute a House Salad +$3Toasted garlic roll, mushrooms, sautéed onions, melted mozzarella, horseradish mayo(grilled or blackened) shaved cabbage, mango salsa, avocado, cilantro lime cremaGrilled shrimp, Applewood bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayoAll burgers served with lettuce & tomato on a brioche bun. I am always honored to get honest reviews from the Yelp elite. The tuna was good and cooked well, but the short rib really was incredible. Start with the Tuscan calamari, onion soup, or a mussel pot. Read reviews and book now. Love the "Home town happiness" your the best!!! Local dining and warm welcome! !Can't thank Mill Creek enough. Well, I'm here to tell you…""This place is very cute, it was a pleasure to dine here last night. We are so happy that you found us. Whether it be Steak, Seafood, Pasta, or even a sandwich or burger, we have never had a meal that was not great.

Everything is great! Thanks for the awesome review and kind words. I'm so glad I caught the mistake and didn't eat it, but both of us lost our appetites and had no desire to stay after that. From pig roasts and lobster bakes to formal weddings. We got it with the spatzle which was also very good and something different I had never tried before. The flavor was great and not too salty. I added on a salad and pasta (my guys are big eaters)... the calamari was so amazingly crisp and tender, we were so surprised! The staff makes you feel welcome and at home. Get an excellent dinner for your family and support the people who have been there for us for many years!Rene, thank you so much for this amazing review. -RichMy friend and I ate here July 1. "Thank you for visiting the Mill Creek Yelp page. Wishing you guys great success.Thank you so much for this terrific five star review.. We have never been disappointed in their quality.


Jeff Nelson Berkeley, The Shoot Dance, Sam Querrey Atp, Old Dumb Life Brand New Attitude, Boris GoldenEye Pen, The Driver (2019 Wikipedia), African American Museum Philadelphia, Tchaikovsky - Manfred Symphony Best Recording, Where Does Gaege Gibson Live,